| |

Two-Toned Gelatin Easter Chicks and Bunnies with Wilton and PEEPS #WiltonTreatTeam

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my Disclosure and Privacy Policy.

I love to spend time in the kitchen.  While I do enjoy cooking, baking is one of my favorite hobbies and one that has been a lot of fun to share with my kids.  One baking brand that I’ve had a long standing relationship with is Wilton. I’ve been one of their Wilton Mom Ambassadors since 2010 and I’m sad to say that program has come to an end. But with endings come new beginnings. Now I’m part of a different Wilton group of bloggers, the Wilton Sweet Treat Team!

Wilton Sweet Treat Team Horizontal

To see the full list of bloggers, check out this Wilton Sweet Treat Team announcement on the Wilton blog.

One of our fun packages we’ve received since this program began was a Easter theme baking box with an assortment of PEEP themed merchandise.  While they may put you in a sugar coma if you eat too many, PEEPS are the epitome of Easter candy fun! This is certainly a very fitting partnership between Wilton and the PEEPS brand.

Wilton Peeps Chicks and Bunnies in Dish Yellow and PinkOne item that caught my eye was the . My mind started spinning on how I could use the mold in a fun and unique way. I decided that a two-toned gelatin chick would be so cute, especially since there were two distinct parts of the cavity for the PEEPS chick.

Two Toned Jello Chicks with Wilton and PeepsI loosely followed these instructions for a Rainbow Ribbon Mold from Kraft.

5 from 9 votes

Two-Tone Gelatin Chicks and Bunnies

Servings 12
Author Emilie, inspired by Kraft


  • 2-1/2 cups boiling water divided if using two different gelatin flavors
  • 2 pkgs. 4-serving size each JELL-O Gelatin (can be same or different flavors)
  • 1/2 cup sour cream or yogurt divided


  1. Spray Wilton 12 cavity PEEPS chicks and bunnies mold with cooking spray.
  2. Add gelatin to medium bowl and add water. (Use two bowls if using different flavors.)
  3. Reserve 1 cup of gelatin if using a single flavor. Set aside.
  4. Bring gelatin to room temperature.
  5. Pour gelatin into molds to 2/3 full.
  6. Refrigerate 15-25 minutes or until gelatin is firm but not set.
  7. Meanwhile, refrigerate reserved gelatin for 5 minutes to thicken slightly.
  8. Stir in sour cream or yogurt to reserved gelatin with whisk until completely combined.
  9. Fill molds completely with creamy gelatin.
  10. Refrigerate 3-4 hours or until completely set.
  11. Gently pop chicks and bunnies out of mold.

Recipe Notes

You will have extra gelatin left over.

The top part of the chick (and bunnies) is made up regular flavored gelatin. I used lemon because that is what I had on hand, but pineapple is another great option. I added french vanilla yogurt for the creamy layer, although sour cream works well too.

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Gelatin Chicks StepsKeep in mind that two boxes of gelatin is necessary to fill the entire 12 cavity mold with extra left over. If you are only interested in a one group of six chicks, one small box is enough.  I decided to make a few grape bunnies with mine and I used some other containers for the excess gelatin. (Can’t let any go to waste!)

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Gelatin Chicks Filled MoldI filled the bunnies 2/3 full with regular gelatin while I filled the entire top of the chick.

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Gelatin Chicks Whisk YogurtIt is important to let your gelatin get firm but not set before adding the next layer. Pour it  too early and it will fall into your first layer. Wait too long and the layers will completely separate when you pop them out of the mold. I recommend letting your gelatin get to room temperature before placing it into the refrigerator. It took about 20 minutes for mine to hit the right stage but you will need to check it closely.

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Gelatin Chicks Fill YogurtAfter a few hours, I popped my gelatin chicks and bunnies out. The chicks were very easy to remove.

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Yellow Jello Chicks

Most of the bunnies came out well but a couple separated a bit. I think the shape is just a bit trickier.

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Gelatin BunniesMy kids loved these, especially my oldest son Lucian. The creamy yogurt layer was their favorite. I can’t blame them. Now I want to make a larger mold with a much larger creamy layer. It is so refreshing!

Wilton Peeps Two Toned Jello BunniesWilton also sent me this fun PEEPS cupcake combo. The bunny ear picks stood out at me.

Wilton Peeps Cupcake Combo

Why not let the gelatin chicks dress up like bunnies? I think they look adorable this way!

Wilton Peeps Pix Bunny Ears in Jello Chicks

No matter how they are served, these PEEPS themed two-toned gelatin treats would be a perfect addition to your Easter or spring celebrations! Look for the PEEPS line at your local craft store. I found a whole display at Michael’s. You can also find seasonal Wilton merchandise at Walmart and Target.


 Disclosure: This post was brought to you in partnership with Wilton as part of the Wilton Sweet Treat Team ambassador program. All thoughts are my own.


  1. How adorable! What child (or adult for that matter) wouldn’t love to be on the receiving end of these Easter goodies!

  2. Cute idea! I prefer jelly candies to the marshmallow. This is a great recipe to have a festive fun candy for Easter.

  3. I want to make these yummy treats for my family for Easter. I put on my To Do list – pick up this mold and kit with Bunny Ears Picks. Thanks for sharing!

  4. 5 stars
    These are so cute! I bought the same mold on sale after Easter. I have got to make these just for fun. Thanks for the recipe!

5 from 9 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating